What evidence did they have that it was him?
Updated November 2026: The verdict and the evidence described below come from coverage published on November 20, 2026. Trial transcripts aren't available to me, so this is what reporters say was presented.
The case was built on circumstantial and digital evidence, not an eyewitness. Reports from the second trial mention:
- Location data: cellphone records and GPS information that prosecutors said placed him near the origin of the Lachman Fire. One account says his phone data showed he was the only person in the area where it started.
- Video and photos: surveillance footage of his car in the Palisades before the fire, and photographs of the car parked at the base of the trail.
- A lighter: a green BIC barbecue lighter, which prosecutors tied to the ignition.
- Holdover theory: investigators' testimony that the Palisades Fire was a continuation of the smaller Lachman Fire, which smoldered for days before reigniting.
- Conduct and statements: his 911 calls, texts and Uber passengers' accounts of him being angry, and a ChatGPT question about cigarettes starting fires, which prosecutors said was an attempt to build an alibi.
The defense argued that nobody saw him start a fire, no camera recorded ignition, the Lachman scene was open to the public for days, and the Palisades Fire's origin is unproven. Its lawyer asked jurors to disregard his texts as "evidence of the man, not evidence of the act." One juror told reporters that the defendant's own testimony was the strongest evidence for him.
Sources differ on the court: most reports say a federal jury in Los Angeles, while CBS Los Angeles says a county jury. The federal reports are more consistent, so I'd rely on them.
🕒 Updated November 2026
