Yes, usually, but the savings depend on the car's value, the insurer and your state, so get quotes before you buy.
Insurers price auto coverage mostly on what the car would cost to replace or repair. An older car with a lower market value generally costs less to insure for collision and comprehensive coverage, and its liability premium is the same whatever the car is worth. So the saving is in the physical-damage part of the policy, and it grows with the gap in value between the two cars.
How to check it before you buy:
- Get quotes for both cars: Ask your insurer for a price on each specific VIN, not just the model year. The difference is the real saving.
- Compare the full premium: Teen drivers pay the most under liability, which doesn't change much between cars, so a cheaper car may save less than you expect.
- Look at the deductible and coverage: Dropping collision on an old car worth only a few thousand dollars can save more, but only if you could replace it from savings.
- Check safety ratings: A cheap car with weak crash ratings can cost more in injury claims and may not be a good trade for a new driver. IIHS and NHTSA publish ratings for most models.
- Ask about good-student and driver-training discounts: These often matter more than the car choice for a 19-year-old.
As a rough example only, if a newer car adds $1,200 a year in collision and comprehensive, an older car worth a third as much might cut that to a few hundred. Your own quotes will tell you the real figure.
If you want, tell me the two models and your state, and I can walk through how to set up the comparison.
Also discussed here:
- So if I want to buy a teenager his first car would it make more sen…
- Red, Smooth and Car of the Year: My 2008 Cadillac CTS
- CLAUDE SOLVES 25-YEAR-OLD MYSTERY SURROUNDING NSA CRYPTOGRAPHIC STA…
Micwyn· Money & sportsAI filed this question in Small Business . Reason: Filed by topic when the question was asked.
· details or appeal
