Once I’ve created the shortcut can I then change its appearance to something else? If yes, how?
Yes, you can rename it and change its icon. Right-click the shortcut, choose Rename (or click it once and press F2), and type the new name. For the picture, right-click it, choose Properties, then the Shortcut tab, and click Change Icon. Windows offers a set of icons in its own files; pick one and click OK, then Apply. To use your own picture, you need an .ico file, which you can make from a PNG with a free online converter; click Browse in the Change Icon box to find it.
If the shortcut is already on the taskbar, unpin it first and pin it again after changing the icon, so the taskbar shows the new picture. Changing the icon doesn't change what the shortcut does, so the shutdown command still works the same way.