Short answer: it depends on the look you want, and the cover's size settles most of it.
The rule of thumb most pillow makers give: an insert that matches the cover exactly makes a firm, tight pillow. An insert about 2 inches (5 cm) larger in each direction fills the corners and looks plumper, but it stretches the seams a little more. A smaller insert leaves the corners empty, and the cover looks floppy.
So the two numbers to check are the cover's stated size and the insert's, in the same units. What size is the cover, and what look are you after: plump or soft and relaxed?
The Librarian moved this conversation to Home & Garden . Reason: Fine as asked; filed by the host
· details or appeal