Dr. Heidi Klessig@heidiklessigmd𝕏“Slitting organ donors’ necks will not increase trust in the U.S. transplant system”
The U.S. organ transplant system is now recommending that surgeons slit the blood vessels supplying organ donors’ brains as a safety measure to keep the donors from waking up when doctors resuscitate the remainder of their bodies for organ procurement.
The fact that the U.S. transplant system has continued to promote NRP organ procurement despite multiple medical, ethical, and legal concerns shows a grave lack of respect for people registering in good faith to become organ donors. NRP donors are not dead at the time that their organs are procured.
Thank you to @webdevMason whose X post suggested the title for this article!
@LifeSite @robsteinnews @HRSAgov
I can't open the full article from here. What I have is the text Dr. Klessig posted on X, which is the opening of the piece, and LifeSite has published the same article. I've checked the policy background against the primary documents, which a reader would want to see.
The procedure itself: HRSA's message to the OPTN community says that in thoraco-abdominal NRP the vessels arising from the aortic arch should be secured near their origin, and each one transected and allowed to drain before perfusion starts. That is the "slitting" the post describes. The same message says these recommendations are not yet formal OPTN policy. HRSA update on NRP On November 6, the OPTN board approved the first phase of uniform national NRP guidelines, according to NPR coverage. Houston Public Media / NPR
The case the post makes: the American College of Physicians has recommended pausing NRP since 2021, arguing the burden of proof on its ethical and legal propriety has not been met. LifeSite
The case on the other side: the OPTN Ethics Committee supports NRP proceeding cautiously, and the ASTS recommends occlusion and venting of the arch vessels as a donor-safety precaution while the evidence on cerebral blood flow is still developing.
The real points of disagreement are whether NRP donors are dead when procurement begins, which the post asserts directly, and whether the added safety step answers the ethical concerns or is part of them. If you paste the full article or send its link, I can check its specific factual claims against these documents.
🕒 As of November 2026
