Sama Hoole@SamaHoole𝕏Eva Perón was 33. She had come from nothing, the illegitimate daughter of a village on the pampas, a radio actress who married the colonel who became president and made herself the voice of Argentina's poor. Millions worshipped her. The generals loathed her. In 1951 she was dying of cervical cancer, and nobody told her.
Not even about the surgery. That November an American cancer surgeon, George Pack, was flown in and brought into the theatre only once she was under anaesthetic, so she would never know a foreigner had operated on her. The cancer came back anyway and spread. By the next spring she was in constant agony, sleepless, raging at the people around her, and her speeches had turned savage. She was talking about arming workers' militias.
Juan Perón sent to Boston for James Poppen of the Lahey Clinic, a neurosurgeon who used the lobotomy on patients in intractable pain. According to Poppen's scrub nurse, interviewed decades later, he first practised the operation on prisoners in Buenos Aires, at Perón's request, before he went to work on her. Two holes were drilled in her skull and the front of her brain was cut.
On 4 June Perón was sworn in for his second term, and Evita rode beside him in the open car, waving to the crowds. She weighed almost nothing. A frame hidden under her long fur coat held her upright.
She grew quiet, then stopped eating. She died on 26 July 1952, and Argentina queued for days to file past her body.
Even the body was given no peace. After the army overthrew Perón in 1955 it was stolen, smuggled to Italy and buried in a Milan cemetery under another woman's name, where it lay for fourteen years.
In 2011 an Argentine neurosurgeon at Yale, Daniel Nijensohn, went back to the X-rays the military had taken of her skull. There were the burr holes, exactly where a lobotomy goes in. He later argued in a neurosurgery journal that the operation was meant to change her behaviour as much as her pain.
The woman who had spoken for millions was quietened by her husband and a visiting surgeon, in her own house, and nobody asked her.
Joseph Kennedy did it to an inconvenient daughter. Juan Perón did it to an inconvenient wife. Both times it was called care.
The core of this post is real history, but the lobotomy part is a contested claim, not established fact. Eva Perón died of cervical cancer on 26 July 1952, and her body was taken from Argentina after the 1955 coup and buried in Milan under another name before returning to Buenos Aires in 1976.
The lobotomy claim comes from Dr George Udvarhelyi, a Hungarian-born neurosurgeon, who said in a 2005 interview that he took part in the operation. Daniel Nijensohn and co-authors then argued for it in a 2011 paper in World Neurosurgery. Their evidence was Udvarhelyi's testimony checked against his memoir, interviews with people around Poppen's clinic, and skull X-rays from 1955 that they found 'compatible with burr holes'. Discover's report on the paper notes that the only direct evidence is Udvarhelyi's testimony, and that the memoir passage is weak support.
Two details in the post need care. Sources differ on the surgeon: some name James Poppen, while Udvarhelyi himself claimed to have performed it. I could not confirm the post's account of a surgeon named George Pack, or of Poppen practising on prisoners first, from the sources I found. The post's 'Joseph Kennedy' comparison is a separate, documented case: Rosemary Kennedy received a prefrontal lobotomy in 1941, and there is a discussion of it in the on-Micwyn conversation about her.
If you want to read further, start with the Nijensohn paper and the critical discussion around it, and weigh the testimony against the documents.
Also discussed here:
- South Africans vote in local elections amid anger over water and power cuts
